Abstract

Despite an increasing reliance on fully-automated algorithmic decision-making in our day-to-day lives, human beings still make highly consequential decisions. As frequently seen in business, healthcare, and public policy, recommendations produced by algorithms are provided to human decision-makers to guide their decisions. While there exists a fast-growing literature evaluating the bias and fairness of such algorithmic recommendations, an overlooked question is whether they help humans make better decisions. We develop a general statistical methodology for experimentally evaluating the causal impacts of algorithmic recommendations on human decisions. We also show how to examine whether algorithmic recommendations improve the fairness of human decisions and derive the optimal decision rules under various settings. We apply the proposed methodology to preliminary data from the first-ever randomized controlled trial that evaluates the pretrial Public Safety Assessment (PSA) in the criminal justice system. A goal of the PSA is to help judges decide which arrested individuals should be released. On the basis of the preliminary data available, we find that providing the PSA to the judge has little overall impact on the judge’s decisions and subsequent arrestee behavior. Our analysis, however, yields some potentially suggestive evidence that the PSA may help avoid unnecessarily harsh decisions for female arrestees regardless of their risk levels while it encourages the judge to make stricter decisions for male arrestees who are deemed to be risky. In terms of fairness, the PSA appears to increase an existing gender difference while having little effect on any racial differences in judges’ decision. Finally, we find that the PSA’s recommendations might be unnecessarily severe unless the cost of a new crime is sufficiently high.

Replication Archive

https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/L0NHQU

Software

aihuman: Experimental Evaluation of Algorithm-Assisted Human Decision-Making — CRAN / GitHub

Related Papers

Zhou, Lingxiao, Kosuke Imai, Jason Lyall, and Georgia Papadogeorgou (2026). ``Dynamic Policy Evaluation and Learning with Spatio-temporal Data.''

Jia, Zeyang, Eli Ben-Michael, and Kosuke Imai (2026). ``Bayesian Safe Policy Learning with Chance Constrained Optimization: Application to Military Security Assessment during the Vietnam War.'' Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A (Statistics in Society), Vol. 189, No. 3, pp. 1448-1472.

Imai, Kosuke, Sooahn Shin, D. James Greiner, and Ryan Halen (2026). ``Triage Score: A Counterfactual Risk Assessment Instrument.''

Koch, Benedikt, Kosuke Imai, and Tomasz Strzalecki (2026). ``An Axiomatic Foundation for Decisions with Counterfactual Utility.''

Koch, Benedikt and Kosuke Imai (2025). ``Statistical Decision Theory with Counterfactual Loss.''

Li, Michael Lingzhi and Kosuke Imai (2025). ``Statistical Performance Guarantee for Subgroup Identification with Generic Machine Learning.''

Ben-Michael, Eli, D. James Greiner, Kosuke Imai, and Zhichao Jiang (2025). ``Safe Policy Learning through Extrapolation: Application to Pre-trial Risk Assessment.'' Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 120, No. 551, pp. 1386-1399.

Ben-Michael, Eli, D. James Greiner, Melody Huang, Kosuke Imai, Zhichao Jiang, Sooahn Shin (2025). ``Does AI help humans make better decisions? A statistical evaluation framework for experimental and observational studies.'' Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 122, No. 38, e2505106122.

Imai, Kosuke and Michael Lingzhi Li (2025). ``Statistical Inference for Heterogeneous Treatment Effects Discovered by Generic Machine Learning in Randomized Experiments.'' Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, Vol. 43, No. 1, pp. 256-268.

Jia, Zeyang, Kosuke Imai, and Michael Lingzhi Li (2025). ``Cramming Contextual Bandits for On-policy Statistical Evaluation.''

Zhang, Yi and Kosuke Imai (2025). ``Individualized Policy Evaluation and Learning under Clustered Network Interference.''

Zhang, Yi, Eli Ben-Michael, and Kosuke Imai (2024). ``Safe Policy Learning under Regression Discontinuity Designs.''

Ben-Michael, Eli, Kosuke Imai, and Zhichao Jiang (2024). ``Policy Learning with Asymmetric Counterfactual Utilities.'' Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 119, No. 548, pp. 3045-3058.

Li, Michael Lingzhi and Kosuke Imai (2024). ``Neyman Meets Causal Machine Learning: Experimental Evaluation of Individualized Treatment Rules.'' Journal of Causal Inference, Vol 12, No. 1, pp. 1-20. Special Issue on Neyman (1923) and its influences on causal inference

Imai, Kosuke and Zhichao Jiang (2023). ``Principal Fairness for Human and Algorithmic Decision-Making.'' Statistical Science, Vol. 38, No. 2 (July), pp317-328.

Imai, Kosuke and Michael Lingzhi Li (2023). ``Experimental Evaluation of Individualized Treatment Rules.'' Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 118, No. 541, pp. 242-256.

Imai, Kosuke, and Aaron Strauss (2011). ``Estimation of Heterogeneous Treatment Effects from Randomized Experiments, with Application to the Optimal Planning of the Get-out-the-vote Campaign.'' Political Analysis, Vol. 19, No. 1 (Winter), pp. 1-19. Winner of Political Analysis Editors' Choice Award.